America’S Test Kitchen Best Toaster: Top Picks for Perfect Toast Every Time

America’s Test Kitchen reviews the best toasters for every kitchen need. Their top picks combine quality, ease of use, and smart features.

Choosing the right toaster can make your mornings easier and tastier. America’s Test Kitchen tested models with wide slots, multiple browning levels, and useful functions like defrost and reheat. From the Mueller UltraToast with four slots to the compact Bella 2 Slice Slim Toaster, these toasters fit different lifestyles and bread types.

Features like removable crumb trays and auto shutoff add safety and convenience. Whether you want to toast bagels, waffles, or regular bread, these toasters deliver consistent results. This guide helps you find a reliable toaster that suits your kitchen and budget. Simple, practical, and designed for everyday use.

Mueller Ultratoast Full Stainless Steel Toaster 4 Slice

The Mueller UltraToast Full Stainless Steel Toaster 4 Slice is ideal for individuals or families who enjoy a versatile and efficient kitchen gadget that can handle a variety of bread types. If you often toast bagels, waffles, or thick slices of bread and appreciate customizable settings, this toaster is designed for you. Its long extra-wide slots and multiple browning levels make it perfect for anyone seeking convenience and precision in their morning routine.

Pros:

• Long extra-wide slots accommodate bagels, waffles, and thick bread slices easily.
• Six browning levels allow for precise toasting preferences.
• LED display provides clear and easy-to-use controls.
• Multiple functions including cancel, defrost, and reheat enhance versatility.
• Full stainless steel construction ensures durability and a sleek, modern look.
• Removable tray simplifies cleaning and maintenance.

Cons:

• Relatively larger size may require more counter space.
• Silver finish may show fingerprints and smudges easily.

The Mueller UltraToast Toaster boasts a robust stainless steel body that not only looks elegant in any kitchen but also promises long-lasting durability. Its long extra-wide slots are designed to fit a variety of bread types, including thick bagels and waffles, eliminating the frustration of uneven toasting or forcing bread into smaller slots. The toaster’s six browning levels give users complete control over their preferred toast color, ensuring a perfect result every time.

With an intuitive LED display and convenient functions such as cancel, defrost, and reheat, this toaster brings flexibility to your breakfast routine. The removable crumb tray makes cleaning effortless, reducing kitchen mess and maintaining the toaster’s performance. Overall, the Mueller UltraToast combines functionality and style, making it a valuable addition to any kitchen looking for a reliable and versatile toasting solution.

To buy this product, click here.

Ge 2 Slice Stainless Steel Toaster

The GE 2 Slice Stainless Steel Toaster is ideal for individuals and families who want a reliable and stylish kitchen appliance to quickly toast a variety of bread products. Whether you enjoy bagels, waffles, or classic slices of bread, this toaster caters to those who value convenience and versatility in their morning routine. Perfect for small kitchens or anyone looking for an efficient countertop essential, it suits users who appreciate adjustable settings and easy maintenance.

Pros:

• Extra wide slots accommodate bagels, waffles, and thick bread slices with ease.
• Offers 7 adjustable shade settings for personalized toasting preferences.
• Equipped with a removable crumb tray for effortless cleaning.
• Sleek stainless steel design complements modern kitchen decor.
• Compact size with dimensions of 7.64” H x 11.18” W x 6.88” L fits well on most countertops.
• 850 watts power ensures fast and even toasting.

Cons:

• Limited to 2 slices at a time, which may not be ideal for larger households.
• Lacks additional functions like defrost or reheat settings found in some toasters.
• No digital display, relying on manual controls for shade settings.

This GE toaster is designed with user convenience in mind, combining a sturdy stainless steel exterior with versatile features to handle a variety of bread types. The wide slots enable easy insertion of bagels and waffles without the need to pre-cut or adjust, while the adjustable shade settings allow users to choose their perfect level of crispiness. The toaster’s compact footprint means it can fit seamlessly on most countertops without taking up excessive space.

Additionally, the inclusion of a removable crumb tray simplifies cleanup, helping maintain the appliance’s efficiency and hygiene. With an 850-watt power output, the toaster heats quickly and evenly, ensuring consistent results every time. Overall, the GE 2 Slice Stainless Steel Toaster offers a great balance of functionality, style, and ease of use, making it a valuable addition to any kitchen.

To buy this product, click here.

Amazon Basics 2 Slice Toaster

The Amazon Basics 2 Slice Toaster is an ideal choice for individuals or small households who want a reliable, efficient, and easy-to-use toaster. If you often enjoy toasted bread, bagels, or special breads and prefer customizable browning options, this toaster fits perfectly. It’s especially suitable for those who value convenience features like extra-wide slots and easy cleaning.

Pros:

• Six browning settings for precise toasting control
• Extra-wide slots accommodate bagels and thicker breads
• Removable crumb tray for effortless cleaning
• Cancel, defrost, and bagel buttons enhance functionality
• Compact design with a sleek black and silver finish
• 900W power ensures quick toasting

Cons:

• Limited to toasting only two slices at a time
• No digital display for browning level
• Basic design may lack advanced features found in premium models

The Amazon Basics 2 Slice Toaster offers a variety of features designed to enhance everyday toasting. The six browning settings allow users to customize the toast to their preferred crispness, ensuring a perfect result every time. Its extra-wide slots are particularly beneficial for toasting bagels and specialty breads that typically don’t fit in standard slots, making it a versatile kitchen appliance.

Moreover, the toaster includes dedicated cancel, defrost, and bagel buttons, adding convenience by allowing users to stop toasting anytime, defrost frozen bread without over-toasting, and toast only one side of a bagel for an ideal texture. The removable crumb tray simplifies cleaning, preventing crumb buildup and maintaining the appliance’s performance and hygiene. Overall, its compact size combined with a sleek black and silver design makes it a stylish and practical addition to any kitchen countertop.

To buy this product, click here.

Hamilton Beach 2 Slice Toaster

The Hamilton Beach 2 Slice Toaster is perfect for individuals or small families who enjoy a quick and easy breakfast. It’s especially ideal for those who appreciate the convenience of having multiple settings to cater to different types of bread, such as bagels and frozen items. If you’re someone who values efficiency and sleek design in kitchen appliances, this toaster is a great match.

Pros:

• Extra-wide slots accommodate various bread sizes, including bagels.
• Toast Boost feature lifts smaller slices for easier retrieval.
• Slide-out crumb tray ensures easy cleaning.
• Auto-Shutoff prevents over-toasting and potential hazards.
• Defrost function allows you to toast frozen items directly.

Cons:

• May require more counter space due to its dimensions.
• The stainless steel exterior may require frequent cleaning to maintain its shine.

The Hamilton Beach 2 Slice Toaster features extra-wide slots, making it versatile enough to handle a variety of bread types, including bagels and artisan bread. This is particularly beneficial for those who enjoy a diverse breakfast menu. The Toast Boost feature is a thoughtful addition, allowing users to easily retrieve smaller slices of bread without burning their fingers.

Another standout feature is the slide-out crumb tray, which simplifies the cleaning process, ensuring your kitchen remains tidy and crumb-free. Additionally, the auto-shutoff feature provides peace of mind by preventing over-toasting, which can be a common issue with traditional toasters. For those who often use frozen bread, the defrost function is a convenient feature that saves time and effort, making this toaster a practical choice for busy mornings.

To buy this product, click here.

Toaster Oven Perfection

The Toaster Oven Perfection: A Smarter Way to Cook on a Smaller Scale is ideal for individuals who value efficiency and versatility in their kitchen appliances. Perfect for small households, apartment dwellers, or anyone with limited kitchen space, this compact yet powerful appliance is designed to streamline cooking without compromising on quality or functionality.

Pros:

• Compact size fits easily in small kitchens and limited counter space.
• Lightweight design at just 1.58 pounds for easy handling and storage.
• Reliable brand from AMERICASTES TKITCHEN and America’s Test Kitchen ensures quality and performance.
• Versatile cooking options suitable for baking, toasting, and broiling.
• Easy to clean due to its simple design and materials.

Cons:

• Limited capacity may not accommodate larger meals or multiple servings at once.
• Basic features may lack advanced settings found in larger, high-end toaster ovens.
• White color may require frequent cleaning to maintain appearance.

The Toaster Oven Perfection excels in delivering a convenient and efficient cooking experience on a smaller scale. Its compact dimensions of 8.7 inches in height, 0.7 inches in width, and 8.01 inches in length make it a perfect fit for those with limited kitchen space. Despite its small size, it offers a broad range of cooking capabilities, allowing users to prepare quick meals without heating a full-sized oven.

Designed by the trusted America’s Test Kitchen, this toaster oven combines quality craftsmanship with user-friendly operation. The lightweight design ensures portability and ease of use, making it ideal for busy individuals or those who appreciate smart kitchen solutions. Overall, the Toaster Oven Perfection is a practical choice for anyone seeking a compact, efficient, and reliable cooking appliance.

To buy this product, click here.

Ultimate Air Fryer Perfection

The Ultimate Air Fryer Perfection: 185 Remarkable Recipes That Make the Most of Your Air Fryer is ideal for cooking enthusiasts and busy individuals who want to explore the full potential of their air fryer. Whether you are a beginner looking to simplify meal prep or an experienced cook aiming to diversify your recipe collection, this book offers an extensive range of dishes tailored to maximize your appliance’s capabilities. It is perfect for anyone seeking healthier cooking alternatives without sacrificing flavor and variety.

Pros:

• Contains 185 diverse recipes suitable for all skill levels.
• Published by America’s Test Kitchen, ensuring tested and reliable instructions.
• Includes an expanded and updated edition with the latest cooking tips.
• Compact and lightweight design makes it easy to handle and store.
• Recipes emphasize healthier cooking techniques with less oil.

Cons:

• Limited to air fryer-specific recipes, which may not suit all cooking preferences.
• Some users may find the 296 pages overwhelming to navigate initially.

The book’s comprehensive approach highlights the versatility of the air fryer, offering recipes that range from quick snacks to full meals. Each recipe is carefully crafted to ensure optimal cooking times and temperatures, helping users achieve consistent, crispy, and delicious results. The inclusion of detailed instructions and tips empowers home cooks to experiment confidently, enhancing their culinary skills while saving time in the kitchen.

Beyond just recipes, the Ultimate Air Fryer Perfection also educates users on the benefits of air frying, such as reduced fat content and faster cooking compared to traditional methods. The thoughtfully updated edition reflects the latest trends and techniques, making it a valuable resource for anyone looking to get the most out of their air fryer. With this guide, users can enjoy a variety of flavorful meals that support a healthier lifestyle without compromising convenience or taste.

To buy this product, click here.

Bella 2 Slice Slim Toaster

The Bella 2 Slice Slim Toaster is ideal for individuals or small households looking for a compact yet efficient kitchen appliance. Perfect for those with limited counter space who still want the flexibility to toast a variety of bread types, including thick slices like sourdough. If you value convenience, style, and precise toasting control, this toaster fits your needs perfectly.

Pros:

• Fits-anywhere™ slim design saves valuable counter space.
• 6 Setting Shade Control allows customization for perfect toasting.
• 10” Long Slot accommodates thick slices of sourdough and other large breads.
• Reheat & Cancel Buttons offer added convenience and control during use.
• Anti Jam & Auto Shutoff features ensure safety and prevent overheating.
• Lightweight at 2.46 pounds for easy handling and storage.

Cons:

• 900 Watt power may result in slightly longer toasting times compared to higher wattage toasters.
• Limited to 2 slices, which may not be suitable for larger families.
• No extra-wide slots for bagels or thicker artisan breads beyond the 10” length.

The Bella 2 Slice Slim Toaster boasts a compact design that fits effortlessly in smaller kitchens without compromising on performance. Its 6 setting shade control provides users with the ability to choose their preferred toast darkness, ensuring every slice is toasted just right. The inclusion of reheat and cancel buttons adds flexibility, allowing users to warm their toast without additional browning or stop the toasting cycle anytime.

One of its standout features is the 10” long slot, specially designed to fit thicker slices of bread such as sourdough, a feature not commonly found in standard toasters. The anti-jam and auto shutoff safety features provide peace of mind during operation, preventing overheating and potential hazards. Overall, this toaster combines safety, convenience, and style, making it a practical addition to any kitchen.

To buy this product, click here.

Elite Gourmet Ect1027b Cool Touch Toaster

The Elite Gourmet ECT1027B Cool Touch Toaster is perfect for individuals or small families who appreciate a combination of style and functionality in their kitchen appliances. Ideal for those who enjoy a variety of toasted goods from bagels to waffles, this toaster is designed for anyone looking for a compact yet versatile toasting solution.

Pros:

• 6 Temperature Settings for customized toasting experience
• Extra Wide 1.25″ Slots accommodate various bread types
• Cool Touch Exterior ensures safety during operation
• ETL Certified for reliable performance and safety

Cons:

• Limited to 2 Slices may not be suitable for larger families
• Black Color may not match all kitchen decors

The Elite Gourmet ECT1027B offers an impressive range of 6 temperature settings, allowing users to achieve the perfect level of toastiness for their bread, from lightly golden to well-done. This feature not only enhances the flavor and texture of your breakfast but also ensures that everyone in the household can enjoy their toast just the way they like it. Moreover, the extra wide 1.25″ slots are specifically designed to handle a variety of bread types, including bagels, waffles, and even specialty breads, making it a versatile addition to your kitchen.

Safety and convenience are at the forefront of this toaster’s design. The cool touch exterior ensures that the appliance remains safe to touch, even during operation, reducing the risk of burns. Additionally, being ETL certified, the toaster meets high safety standards, providing peace of mind while delivering reliable performance. Its compact dimensions make it an ideal choice for those with limited counter space, and its sleek black color complements modern kitchen aesthetics.

To buy this product, click here.

Elite Gourmet Ect-3100 Long Slot 4 Slice Toaster

The Elite Gourmet ECT-3100 Long Slot 4 Slice Toaster is ideal for individuals and families who want a versatile and efficient kitchen appliance. If you often prepare breakfast or snacks involving bread, bagels, or waffles and appreciate customizable toasting options, this toaster is perfect for you. Its extra-wide slots and multiple functions make it suitable for those who value convenience, speed, and precision in their morning routine.

Pros:

• Extra wide slots accommodate bagels, waffles, and thick slices easily.
• Six adjustable toast settings for perfect browning control.
• Multiple functions including reheat, defrost, and cancel for versatility.
• Built-in warming rack keeps food warm after toasting.
• Durable stainless steel and black design fits modern kitchens.
• Compact dimensions make it easy to place on most countertops.

Cons:

• Long slots may not fit smaller bread slices as snugly, potentially leading to uneven toasting.
• Limited to four slices, which might be insufficient for larger households.
• No digital display, which some users may prefer for precise control.

The Elite Gourmet ECT-3100 features extra-wide long slots designed to toast a variety of bread types, including bagels and waffles, without the hassle of squeezing them in. This flexibility ensures that users can prepare different breakfast items with ease. The six toast settings allow for customizable browning, so each user can achieve their preferred crispness. Additionally, the reheat, defrost, and cancel functions add to the toaster’s user-friendly design, offering convenience and control at any time.

Constructed with a sleek combination of stainless steel and black accents, this toaster not only performs well but also adds a modern touch to your kitchen. Its built-in warming rack is a thoughtful feature that keeps your toasted items warm while you prepare the rest of your meal. Compact yet efficient, the Elite Gourmet ECT-3100 balances functionality and style, making it a practical choice for everyday use.

To buy this product, click here.

Mecity 2 Slice Toaster

The Mecity 2 Slice Toaster Touch Screen is perfect for individuals and families who value convenience and versatility in their kitchen appliances. Ideal for those who enjoy a variety of breads including bagels, muffins, waffles, and gluten-free options, this toaster offers an easy-to-use, smart solution for quick and precise toasting. If you are looking for a reliable, sleek, and feature-rich toaster that complements a modern kitchen, this stainless steel model is an excellent choice.

Pros:

• Features a touch screen for intuitive and easy control
• 1.5″ wide slots accommodate thick slices, bagels, and waffles
• Multiple functions including timer, defrost, and reheat settings
• Compact size with stainless steel finish blends well with any kitchen decor
• Operates at 120V 825W, ensuring efficient toasting performance

Cons:

• Limited to 2 slices at a time, which may not be sufficient for larger families
• Touch screen controls may have a learning curve for users accustomed to traditional buttons
• Requires a power outlet with 120V compatibility, limiting use in some regions

The Mecity 2 Slice Toaster stands out with its advanced touch screen interface, allowing users to easily select desired toasting settings with precision. Its 1.5-inch wide slots provide the flexibility to toast a variety of bread types, from thick gluten-free slices to bagels and waffles, enhancing the breakfast experience. The toaster’s compact dimensions (7.0 inches high, 6.2 inches wide, and 10.4 inches long) make it ideal for kitchens with limited counter space without sacrificing performance.

Equipped with smart features such as a timer, defrost, and reheat functions, this toaster ensures your bread is toasted exactly to your preference every time. The stainless steel construction not only adds a modern aesthetic but also offers durability and easy cleaning. With a power rating of 825W, it heats up quickly and efficiently, making it an excellent choice for anyone seeking a dependable and stylish toaster for daily use.

To buy this product, click here.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Features Make Mueller Ultratoast Stand Out?

Mueller UltraToast offers 4 slices with extra-wide slots. It includes 6 browning levels, LED display, and multiple functions like cancel, defrost, and reheat. Its full stainless steel design ensures durability and easy cleaning with a removable crumb tray.

How Does Ge 2 Slice Toaster Handle Different Breads?

GE’s 2 Slice Toaster has extra-wide slots perfect for bagels, waffles, and thick breads. It offers 7 shade settings for precise toasting and a removable crumb tray for easy cleanup. Its 850-watt power ensures consistent and quick results.

What Are The Benefits Of Amazon Basics 2 Slice Toaster?

Amazon Basics 2 Slice Toaster features 6 browning settings and wide slots for various breads. It includes cancel, defrost, and bagel buttons for convenience. The removable crumb tray simplifies cleaning, and its 900W power delivers efficient toasting every time.

Why Choose Hamilton Beach 2 Slice Toaster?

Hamilton Beach’s 2 Slice Toaster has extra-wide slots and a bagel setting. It features toast boost, auto shutoff, cancel button, and defrost function. The stainless steel build and slide-out crumb tray add durability and ease of use in any kitchen.

How Does Elite Gourmet Ect-3100 4 Slice Toaster Perform?

Elite Gourmet ECT-3100 offers 4 slices with extra-wide slots. It has reheat, defrost, and cancel functions plus 6 toast settings. The built-in warming rack keeps food warm, and its stainless steel and black design fits modern kitchens well.

What Smart Features Does Mecity 2 Slice Toaster Include?

Mecity 2 Slice Toaster has a touchscreen with 1. 5” wide slots. It supports bagels, muffins, waffles, and gluten-free breads. The timer, defrost, and reheat functions enhance usability. Its stainless steel design combines style with efficient, smart toasting.

Conclusion

Choosing the right toaster can make your breakfast routine easier and more enjoyable. Each model on America’s Test Kitchen list offers useful features like wide slots, multiple browning levels, and easy-to-clean trays. Whether you need a simple two-slice toaster or one that can handle bagels and waffles, there is an option for you.

Some toasters have extra settings like defrost and reheat to save time and reduce waste. Stainless steel designs are common, giving a sleek look and lasting durability. Think about what fits your kitchen space and daily needs. A good toaster should be safe, quick, and reliable.

With these options, you can find a toaster that fits your budget and style. Breakfast can be simple and tasty with the right kitchen gadget. Choose wisely and enjoy fresh, perfectly toasted bread every day.